Skip to content
BETA

Published vs unpublished - website / MLS / Instagram

Current as of Tuesday, September 1, 2026. General information, not legal advice.

RightsValet Copyright Guide: all sections

Ready to register your photos? Request an invitation

This is the highest-stakes publication question for real-estate and commercial photographers, because GRPPH and GRUPH cannot be mixed and the applicant must decide.

15.1 Statutory definition

17 U.S.C. § 101:

“‘Publication’ is the distribution of copies or phonorecords of a work to the public by sale or other transfer of ownership, or by rental, lease, or lending. The offering to distribute copies or phonorecords to a group of persons for purposes of further distribution, public performance, or public display, constitutes publication. A public performance or display of a work does not of itself constitute publication.”

Circular 42: “For copyright purposes, a photograph is published on the specific month, day, and year that a copy or multiple copies of that work are distributed to the public for the first time. A photograph is also published when copies of that work are offered to a group of persons for the first time for purposes of further distribution or public display. The public display of a photograph, in and of itself, does not constitute publication.”

Compendium ch. 1900 § 1904.1: “The applicant - not the U.S. Copyright Office - must determine whether a work is published or unpublished.” The Office “will not give specific legal advice on whether a particular work has or has not been published.”

Compendium example (ch. 1900 § 1906.1): “Publication occurs when copies of a photograph are offered to clients, including but not limited to newspapers, magazines, agencies, wire services, and websites with a license permitting further distribution or display of the photograph.”

15.2 Online publication - Compendium Chapter 1000, § 1008.3

GRPPH/GRUPH help: “For information concerning online publication, see Compendium … Chapter 1000, Section 1008.3.” Key rules:

  1. Applicant decides. The Office will accept the applicant’s representation unless that statement is implausible or is contradicted. § 1008.3(F).
  2. Authorization is essential. “To be considered published, the copyright owner must expressly or impliedly authorize users to make retainable copies … whether by downloading, printing, or by other means.” Unauthorized posting (scraping, client posting without permission, infringement) does not publish the work. § 1008.3(C), (F).
  3. Mere online display ≠ publication. Buffer/cache copies made while browsing are irrelevant. § 1008.3(B), (E).
  4. Download authorization = publication. “If a work is expressly made available for download the work is deemed published, because a distribution occurs each time a user downloads a copy.” § 1008.3(F).
  5. Offer to a group of intermediaries = publication even with no actual downstream use. Photographer offering a photograph “to multiple stock photo companies or website for purposes of further distribution or public display” creates a reasonable inference of publication. § 1008.3(B). Same structure as the AP/UPI example in § 1114.1.
  6. Express no-copy notice supports unpublished. § 1008.3(F).
  7. Implied license / silent Instagram-style post is fact-specific and may be unclear. Factors in § 1008.3(D): download/save/email buttons; copyright reservation; technical barriers to copy/save/print; stream/display-only vs. copy permission.
  8. Same work also distributed in hard copy is published, even if the online posting by itself would not publish it. § 1008.3(F).

Compendium § 1114.1 photograph examples: transmitting 600 photos to a publisher with a license to distribute or display = all 600 published that day, even if the publisher later uses only three. Offering 500 photos to AP and UPI with a license to further distribute/display = all 500 published, even if unused. Wedding photographer posting in a password-protected folder and sending the couple a link plus a license to download and retain = published on the date made available for download, not the date they actually downloaded. Commercial photographer sending an electronic proof sheet stating images “could not be used without her permission” = unpublished. Sending selected retouched files with a license to use = published on the send dates.

15.3 Application to real-estate / commercial / Instagram (Office doctrine - not a court holding)

The Office has not published a circular that names “MLS” or “Instagram” as magic words. The following applies Compendium §§ 1008.3 and 1114.1 to those fact patterns. Label the last inch Office-doctrine application, not a regulation.

Fact pattern Likely Office analysis Typical registration path
Photographer posts images on a personal/promotional site for viewing only, with copyright notice / no-download terms, no client license to retain Public display; unpublished (§ 1008.3(B), (C), (F)) GRUPH
Photographer’s site has a “download / high-res / purchase prints” control, or expressly authorizes saving Published on the date authorized copies were offered (§ 1008.3(F)) GRPPH for that calendar year
Photographer delivers files to one client with a license to download and retain (proof gallery, WeTransfer, Dropbox, PhotoShelter) Published when made available under that license - even if the client never downloads GRPPH
Photographer sends a proof sheet “not to be used without permission,” no retain/use license Unpublished (Lois Lang example, § 1114.6(G)) GRUPH
Photographer licenses images to a listing broker who is authorized to put them on MLS for further display/distribution to member brokers and the public Offer to a group of persons (MLS participants) for further distribution or public display → published under § 101 sentence 2 and § 1008.3(B) stock-photo/wire-service analogy GRPPH, year of the MLS offer
Broker or seller posts the photographer’s images on MLS / brokerage site without the photographer’s authorization Does not publish the photographer’s work (§ 1008.3(C), (F) unauthorized posting) Still GRUPH if the photographer never authorized distribution; separately an infringement
Instagram / Facebook / similar, posted by the photographer for display, no download button, no license to retain copies Office: display alone is not publication; silent terms of service may make status unclear (§ 1008.3(F)). Applicant’s call. Applicant’s determination. Many photographers treat display-only social posts as unpublished; that is consistent with § 1008.3(B) if they did not authorize retainable copies.
Instagram post plus an offer that followers may download, or a stock-style license, or delivery of retainable files Published GRPPH

Do not treat the Copyright Alliance FAQ as a primary source. Office circulars/Compendium do not use a “multiple-clients-display = publication” formulation in so many words. The closest primary-source analog is § 101’s “offering to distribute copies … to a group of persons for purposes of … public display.” If the photographer offered copies (files) to a group of clients for them to display, that is the AP/UPI fact pattern and is published. If the photographer merely displayed the same image on his own site, that is not.

Office recommendation: register with GRUPH before sharing files with any other party. Compendium § 1114.5: “In the case of unpublished photographs, the Office strongly encourages applicants to register their photos before sharing them with any other party.”

15.4 Consequences of getting publication status wrong

  1. Wrong group path: Mixing published + unpublished in one group → ineligible; Office may refuse or require amendment (Circular 42; 37 C.F.R. § 202.4). Selecting the wrong option → start over.
  2. Wrong deposit rules: Published U.S. works may require best-edition / two-copy rules; unpublished / online-only typically one complete copy / electronic upload.
  3. Wrong remedy timeline: Statutory damages / attorney’s fees generally require registration before infringement or within 3 months after first publication (17 U.S.C. § 412). Misstating publication date can affect that analysis and § 410(c) prima facie weight.
  4. Correction limits: Circular 8 / Compendium ch. 1800 - supplementary registration can clarify that a work registered as published was unpublished; can correct publication date if corrected date is same as or earlier than EDR of basic registration. Cannot use supplementary registration to “add a date of publication to the original registration for an unpublished work” in the usual case - instead file a new basic registration for the first published edition under 17 U.S.C. § 408(e). A date of publication cannot be added to a group of unpublished photographs. § 1802.7(C).
  5. False material fact: 17 U.S.C. § 506(e) - knowing false representation of a material fact in an application → fine up to $2,500 (also noted on Form VA).