Published vs unpublished - website / MLS / Instagram
Current as of Tuesday, September 1, 2026. General information, not legal advice.
Ready to register your photos? Request an invitation
This is the highest-stakes publication question for real-estate and commercial photographers, because GRPPH and GRUPH cannot be mixed and the applicant must decide.
15.1 Statutory definition
17 U.S.C. § 101:
“‘Publication’ is the distribution of copies or phonorecords of a work to the public by sale or other transfer of ownership, or by rental, lease, or lending. The offering to distribute copies or phonorecords to a group of persons for purposes of further distribution, public performance, or public display, constitutes publication. A public performance or display of a work does not of itself constitute publication.”
Circular 42: “For copyright purposes, a photograph is published on the specific month, day, and year that a copy or multiple copies of that work are distributed to the public for the first time. A photograph is also published when copies of that work are offered to a group of persons for the first time for purposes of further distribution or public display. The public display of a photograph, in and of itself, does not constitute publication.”
Compendium ch. 1900 § 1904.1: “The applicant - not the U.S. Copyright Office - must determine whether a work is published or unpublished.” The Office “will not give specific legal advice on whether a particular work has or has not been published.”
Compendium example (ch. 1900 § 1906.1): “Publication occurs when copies of a photograph are offered to clients, including but not limited to newspapers, magazines, agencies, wire services, and websites with a license permitting further distribution or display of the photograph.”
15.2 Online publication - Compendium Chapter 1000, § 1008.3
GRPPH/GRUPH help: “For information concerning online publication, see Compendium … Chapter 1000, Section 1008.3.” Key rules:
- Applicant decides. The Office will accept the applicant’s representation unless that statement is implausible or is contradicted. § 1008.3(F).
- Authorization is essential. “To be considered published, the copyright owner must expressly or impliedly authorize users to make retainable copies … whether by downloading, printing, or by other means.” Unauthorized posting (scraping, client posting without permission, infringement) does not publish the work. § 1008.3(C), (F).
- Mere online display ≠ publication. Buffer/cache copies made while browsing are irrelevant. § 1008.3(B), (E).
- Download authorization = publication. “If a work is expressly made available for download the work is deemed published, because a distribution occurs each time a user downloads a copy.” § 1008.3(F).
- Offer to a group of intermediaries = publication even with no actual downstream use. Photographer offering a photograph “to multiple stock photo companies or website for purposes of further distribution or public display” creates a reasonable inference of publication. § 1008.3(B). Same structure as the AP/UPI example in § 1114.1.
- Express no-copy notice supports unpublished. § 1008.3(F).
- Implied license / silent Instagram-style post is fact-specific and may be unclear. Factors in § 1008.3(D): download/save/email buttons; copyright reservation; technical barriers to copy/save/print; stream/display-only vs. copy permission.
- Same work also distributed in hard copy is published, even if the online posting by itself would not publish it. § 1008.3(F).
Compendium § 1114.1 photograph examples: transmitting 600 photos to a publisher with a license to distribute or display = all 600 published that day, even if the publisher later uses only three. Offering 500 photos to AP and UPI with a license to further distribute/display = all 500 published, even if unused. Wedding photographer posting in a password-protected folder and sending the couple a link plus a license to download and retain = published on the date made available for download, not the date they actually downloaded. Commercial photographer sending an electronic proof sheet stating images “could not be used without her permission” = unpublished. Sending selected retouched files with a license to use = published on the send dates.
15.3 Application to real-estate / commercial / Instagram (Office doctrine - not a court holding)
The Office has not published a circular that names “MLS” or “Instagram” as magic words. The following applies Compendium §§ 1008.3 and 1114.1 to those fact patterns. Label the last inch Office-doctrine application, not a regulation.
| Fact pattern | Likely Office analysis | Typical registration path |
|---|---|---|
| Photographer posts images on a personal/promotional site for viewing only, with copyright notice / no-download terms, no client license to retain | Public display; unpublished (§ 1008.3(B), (C), (F)) | GRUPH |
| Photographer’s site has a “download / high-res / purchase prints” control, or expressly authorizes saving | Published on the date authorized copies were offered (§ 1008.3(F)) | GRPPH for that calendar year |
| Photographer delivers files to one client with a license to download and retain (proof gallery, WeTransfer, Dropbox, PhotoShelter) | Published when made available under that license - even if the client never downloads | GRPPH |
| Photographer sends a proof sheet “not to be used without permission,” no retain/use license | Unpublished (Lois Lang example, § 1114.6(G)) | GRUPH |
| Photographer licenses images to a listing broker who is authorized to put them on MLS for further display/distribution to member brokers and the public | Offer to a group of persons (MLS participants) for further distribution or public display → published under § 101 sentence 2 and § 1008.3(B) stock-photo/wire-service analogy | GRPPH, year of the MLS offer |
| Broker or seller posts the photographer’s images on MLS / brokerage site without the photographer’s authorization | Does not publish the photographer’s work (§ 1008.3(C), (F) unauthorized posting) | Still GRUPH if the photographer never authorized distribution; separately an infringement |
| Instagram / Facebook / similar, posted by the photographer for display, no download button, no license to retain copies | Office: display alone is not publication; silent terms of service may make status unclear (§ 1008.3(F)). Applicant’s call. | Applicant’s determination. Many photographers treat display-only social posts as unpublished; that is consistent with § 1008.3(B) if they did not authorize retainable copies. |
| Instagram post plus an offer that followers may download, or a stock-style license, or delivery of retainable files | Published | GRPPH |
Do not treat the Copyright Alliance FAQ as a primary source. Office circulars/Compendium do not use a “multiple-clients-display = publication” formulation in so many words. The closest primary-source analog is § 101’s “offering to distribute copies … to a group of persons for purposes of … public display.” If the photographer offered copies (files) to a group of clients for them to display, that is the AP/UPI fact pattern and is published. If the photographer merely displayed the same image on his own site, that is not.
Office recommendation: register with GRUPH before sharing files with any other party. Compendium § 1114.5: “In the case of unpublished photographs, the Office strongly encourages applicants to register their photos before sharing them with any other party.”
15.4 Consequences of getting publication status wrong
- Wrong group path: Mixing published + unpublished in one group → ineligible; Office may refuse or require amendment (Circular 42; 37 C.F.R. § 202.4). Selecting the wrong option → start over.
- Wrong deposit rules: Published U.S. works may require best-edition / two-copy rules; unpublished / online-only typically one complete copy / electronic upload.
- Wrong remedy timeline: Statutory damages / attorney’s fees generally require registration before infringement or within 3 months after first publication (17 U.S.C. § 412). Misstating publication date can affect that analysis and § 410(c) prima facie weight.
- Correction limits: Circular 8 / Compendium ch. 1800 - supplementary registration can clarify that a work registered as published was unpublished; can correct publication date if corrected date is same as or earlier than EDR of basic registration. Cannot use supplementary registration to “add a date of publication to the original registration for an unpublished work” in the usual case - instead file a new basic registration for the first published edition under 17 U.S.C. § 408(e). A date of publication cannot be added to a group of unpublished photographs. § 1802.7(C).
- False material fact: 17 U.S.C. § 506(e) - knowing false representation of a material fact in an application → fine up to $2,500 (also noted on Form VA).