Skip to content
BETA

Twenty-item Visual Arts refusal / correspondence list

Current as of Tuesday, September 1, 2026. General information, not legal advice.

RightsValet Copyright Guide: all sections

Ready to register your photos? Request an invitation

Drawn from Circular 42, Compendium chs. 900 / 1100 / 1500 / 1800, 37 C.F.R. § 202.4, eCO GRUPH/GRPPH help, 83 FR 2544–46 (examination pain points that drove the 750 cap), and the processing-times FAQ (27% of claims generate correspondence). The Office does not publish a ranked “top refusals” list for photographs; these are the issues the primary sources repeatedly flag. Compendium § 1105.3: “the Office strictly applies the requirements for these group registration options.” Specialists may correspond if the problem is easily fixed; otherwise they refuse and tell the applicant to file work-by-work. Respond within 45 days.

  1. Wrong group type selected (published vs unpublished; Standard Application, Single Application, paper Form VA, or GRUW used for a 750-photo claim). Must start over. Circular 42; Compendium § 1114.6: “If an applicant attempts to use the Standard Application or a paper application, the U.S. Copyright Office will refuse registration and instruct the applicant to resubmit the claim using the appropriate form. This will require a new filing fee and deposit and will result in a later effective date of registration.”

  2. Mixed publication status in one group (published + unpublished photographs). Circular 42; GRPPH/GRUPH help; 37 C.F.R. § 202.4(h)(6), (i)(6); Compendium § 1114.1.

  3. Published photos from more than one calendar year (GRPPH). 37 C.F.R. § 202.4(i)(6); GRPPH help. Different years in earliest/latest fields are rejected by the electronic system. Compendium § 1114.6(G). Split into separate applications by year.

  4. More than 750 photographs in one application. Specialist may register the first 750 on the title list and strip the rest, or refuse the whole claim. Circular 42; Compendium § 1114.1; 37 C.F.R. § 202.4(h)(2), (i)(2), (p); help pages.

  5. Multiple authors (second shooter, assistant, drone pilot) on a group claim, unless all WFH for one employer named as author of each and identified as WFH. Circular 42; 37 C.F.R. § 202.4(h)(3)–(4), (i)(3)–(4). Mixing WFH photos with assigned photos. Compendium § 1114.6(I)(2). Mixed claimants. Joint-work groups are high-risk / likely refused under 2018 FR practice (81 FR 86650; 83 FR 2546 n.18).

  6. Claimant is not the copyright owner (client, licensee, stock user, website owner without written transfer of all exclusive rights). Circular 1; Circular 30; Compendium ch. 400; Compendium § 1114.6(K). A mere exclusive licensee of fewer than all rights cannot be named as claimant. Registering a licensed stock photo as if you authored it is a material misstatement (17 U.S.C. § 506(e)).

  7. File names do not match the numbered title list, or list missing / wrong format / missing case number in the list filename. Circular 42; 37 C.F.R. § 202.4(h)(10), (i)(10); Compendium § 1114.6(A): specialist “may ask the applicant to exclude that photo from the claim, or he or she may simply refuse registration.” CSV is not a listed format.

  8. Wrong deposit format (RAW, PNG, HEIC, PSD, PDF images, prints, contact sheets, PCD, corrupt zip); upload > 500 MB; hundreds of individual (non-ZIP) uploads. Circular 42; Compendium § 1114.4(A); 83 FR 2544 (these examination failures justified the 750 cap). Group-photo rule: JPEG / GIF / TIFF only.

  9. Slavish copy / scan of 2-D art; claims in “scanned,” “digitized,” “restored,” “touchup,” “digital editing.” Compendium §§ 909.3(A), 917, 1114.6(J). The electronic group-photo system “will not accept claims in ‘digital editing,’ ‘compilation,’ or any other form of authorship other than ‘photographs.’” Cannot be added later by supplementary registration.

  10. Insufficient creativity (Office will not register photographs that lack a sufficient amount of creative expression). Circular 42; Compendium § 909.1; Compendium § 1114 (each photo is examined). Rare for ordinary photography; more common for mechanical reproductions, medical x-rays and similar functional imaging (Compendium § 909.3(B), citing Burrow-Giles), and some product-on-white work that is a mere copy of a preexisting 2-D design.

  11. Derivative work with no limitation of claim (edited third-party or previously published photo; AI-generated regions not disclaimed). Circular 14; Compendium § 907; 88 FR 16190 (duty to disclose more-than-de-minimis AI-generated content). Failure to disclose AI can lead to cancellation (37 C.F.R. § 201.7(c)(4)) or § 411(b) inaccuracy problems.

  12. Unlawful derivative (no permission to use the underlying work). 17 U.S.C. § 103(a); Compendium § 907.2. The specialist may inquire whether permission was obtained when a recognizable preexisting work is incorporated. If preexisting material was used unlawfully, the Office will refuse.

  13. Work-made-for-hire box inconsistent with author/claimant names or with the nine statutory categories. Circular 30; Compendium § 614. Naming the employee/individual creator as author of a WFH (Compendium § 614.2(B)(3)). Treating a freelance house shoot as WFH when photographs are not a stand-alone commissioned-WFH category. Circ. 30 Q7; Compendium § 506.3. Naming an organization as author without answering WFH “yes.” eCO Author help.

  14. Deposit does not match the claim (titles, counts, authorship described but not in the files). Compendium § 1008.1; processing-times FAQ. Physical deposit mailed without the eCO shipping slip: Office cannot match deposit to application; extra search fee; if lost, resubmission changes the effective date. Compendium § 1114.4(B).

  15. Publication date implausible (applicant treated a public display as publication, or vice versa). Compendium §§ 1904.3, 1908, 1008.3. Office generally accepts the representation unless it is implausible or contradicted. Mixing published photos from different nations is allowed (2018 final rule dropped same-country requirement) but should be noted.

  16. Attempting to fix publication-status / group-type errors with supplementary registration when a new basic application is required. Compendium §§ 1802.4, 1802.7(C). Cannot add a date of publication to a group of unpublished photographs. Cannot change a group of published photographs into a compilation, collective work, or photographic database (or vice versa). Subsequent ownership transfers belong in § 205 recordation, not supplementary registration.

  17. Claim in uncopyrightable subject matter rather than in the photograph: ideas, layout/format of a website, logos consisting of lettering only, useful articles, x-rays/medical imaging, purely AI-generated images, prompts-only outputs. Compendium §§ 306, 313.2, 906, 909.3(B), 914, 1007; 88 FR 16190; Part 2 (Jan. 2025); Review Board Paradise, Zarya, Théâtre, SURYAST. 37 C.F.R. § 202.1 (names/titles/slogans, familiar symbols, mere coloring, ideas, blank forms, typeface).

  18. No response to examiner correspondence within 45 days, or incomplete response. Processing-times FAQ. Claim may be closed. Eligibility-checkbox not honestly met: application requires “I agree that I have read, understood, and meet all eligibility requirements.” Compendium § 1114.6(B). A false material representation is a crime under 17 U.S.C. § 506(e) (fine up to $2,500). Compendium § 1114.6(O); Form VA.

  19. Physical deposit mailed after an electronic application, or best-edition issues for published works that were also issued in physical form; using unit of publication for photographs first published online or in digital form; using GR2D for ordinary photographs; treating a website or catalog as a photographic database. Circular 42; Circular 34; Compendium §§ 1103.1(E), 1112.3; GR2D help (“As a general rule, photographs should not be submitted for registration with the GR2D application.”); registration FAQ.

  20. Generic titles (“Untitled”) making the public record unusable - not always a refusal, but the Office warns against them. Registration FAQ; Compendium §§ 610.6, 1114.6(A). Related record-quality issues: omitting individual titles from the application (they then do not appear on the certificate or online public catalog - Circular 42 / Compendium § 1114.6(D)); post-issuance cancellation if the Office later finds the group option’s requirements were not met and the claimant does not cure. 37 C.F.R. §§ 202.4(q), 201.7; Compendium § 1105.3. Non-photographs in a photo group (text, illustrations, artwork, collages, video). Circ. 42; Compendium § 1114.1.

If refused: Administrative reconsideration (two requests) is available under 37 C.F.R. § 202.5; Compendium ch. 1700. Special handling is not available for reconsideration. Circular 10. After a final refusal, the applicant may still sue under § 411(a) by serving the Register - but the CCB cannot hear a claim on a refused registration. ccb.gov FAQ.